« Of Pan's Labyrinth | Main | Conducting the Charitable Giving Conversation as a Rational Person Would »

June 08, 2011


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Keith Whitaker


Kudos on tossing rotten tomatoes at the self-important, self-deluded rich or consultants to the rich. But hyping a turgid, derivative thinker who work led to mass murder in Eastern Europe, Asia, South America, and Africa? Just because some journalists on the left complain about feeling "bleak" and uninspired? C'mon. I would have expected you to give these whiners a kick in the pants rather than to join their chorus. Unless perhaps the dumpster is becoming a partisan pulpit ...

Best wishes,


Phil Cubeta

I am not sure the post came out much in favor of Marx, Gladwell, or Nader. The point was about the ubiquity of one world view today, Wealth Bondage as the Will of God. What would you contrast with that worldview? There is no outside of wealth bondage, particularly for those who pursue a career, a calling, counseling the wealthy on their, shall we say, ethics, aesthetics, spirituality, or whatever one calls that dumb prompting of the holy spirit. I appreciate your dropping by, Keith.

Keith Whitaker

Thanks, Phil. I always drop by when my digital master tells me there's a new post. I wish there were more discussion! Thanks for the clarification of your point. It sounds similar to Georg Simmel's argument (in a really tiny nutshell) that abstract money has become the contemporary expression of the unifying principle once known as God. Properly understood, I think it is a powerful claim. However, not to sound too Heideggerian, I think we all can see around us and within us a great deal of longing for something much more like the old God. That's what I, at least, see behind those "dumb promptings": not the presence of the holy spirit but its absence tugging at the heartstrings.

Keith Whitaker, www.wisecounselresearch.org

tom matrullo

That's beautifully put. The mythos that we obstinately continue to desire, without portfolio to get there.

Have you perhaps seen The Ister?

Phil Cubeta

I wish there were more conversation, too, Keith, particularly of the calibre of your comments and Tom's. How the emptiness where spirit once was drives us - I sometimes feel that Heidgger is a symptom more than a cure of rootless modernity longing for the submlime. Where the genuine leaves a hole, the bogus enters.

Jon Husband

I like to believe I've felt this void-ness growing over the years, and I fret that there's no way out of Bogosity Bondage in this modern noise-and-delusion filled era.

You know something's up when (in his own words) the 2nd most popular comedian on cable tv is delivering the commencement speech at a reputable university. In the closing (from about 16h00 on .. ) he exhorts the graduands to a life of improvisation underpinned by genuine service to others.

"Even if you get your dream, it's important for you to know that you are not a winner ..." etc.

An ode to service ... well done Stephen.

Phil Cubeta

The mood in some quarters is receptive to that ode to service, so I am finding by addressing people in that spirit. The politicians have left that space open. What is so ugly about the entrenchment of power and money are the lies and divisiveness needed to support it. Better that, though, than overt oppression backed by violence. But lies and hatred are a good forerunner of that.

Jon Husband

What is so ugly about the entrenchment of power and money are the lies and divisiveness needed to support it.

The heart of the matter. An enduring problem for which I cannot see an end, unfortunately it corrodes the souls of all it touches, penetrates and surrounds. The corrosion of character suffocates life.


"There must be some kind of way out of here,"
Said the joker to the thief,
"There's too much confusion,
I can't get no relief.
Businessman they drink my wine,
Plowman dig my earth
None will level on the line, nobody offered his word, hey"

J. Hendrix

Phil Cubeta

Lies legitimated by force and vice versa. Teach your children well that they might rise.

Ben Turpin

Oh fer chrissakes, the longing for the old god always was the old god. That's why they had to invent Jesus - to stop time!

It didn't work.

Phil Cubeta

Jesus will come again to judge the living and the dead, having harrowed hell. That is what will stop time.

The comments to this entry are closed.


Wealth Bondage Premium Content

  • Castle by the Sea
    Provided as a professional courtesy at no extra charge to those with net worth of $25 million or more and/or family income of $500,000 a year or more, and to their Serving Professionals of all genders.