« Dick Wagner at Worth Living | Main | Sue Braiden »

August 21, 2004

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Daniel F. Bassill

I would like to see this concept carried a bit further. I would like to see those who are fortunate enough to be in conversations with the powerful act as an intermediary who leads their network of friends through portals that provide information on where they are needed, why they are needed and how they can apply their resources as reinforcments in places where good work is being done, but reinforcements of people, dollars, ideas, technology, etc. are needed.

While I'm sure this is happening all the time, I'm not sure that many portals use maps of geographic areas to show where need for a particular type of social enterprise is most needed, or to show what enterprises are already operating within specific areas.

Without the map it is too easy for a powerful person or organization to make a significant impact in one location and feel the job is done. With the map one can quickly see that such impact is needed in many locations.

I'd also like to see visual charts that illustrate the timeline needed to accomplish a goal. Such charts would help the powerful see that short-term involvement usually does little to have an impact on complicated issues.

I don't need to be in the conversation with the wealthy if someone who is in that conversation is drawing the wealthy and powerful through a portal that shows them the battlfield and where they are needed.

At www.tutormentorexchange.net you can see maps of Chicago that illustrate where poverty and poorly performing schools are concentrated. This is our battlefield. You can find links to dozens of organizations working in Chicago and other cities to mentor and tutor kids. Each needs a more consistent flow of volunteers, dollars and technology.

For those in conversations with the wealthy and powerful, this is a portal that you can use to bring your friends to this effort.

While I use my own work to demonstrate the point, I beleive that maps and visual roadmaps could be used effectively by many causes in many cities to connect those who can help with those who need help.

Phil

Your site is an excellent resource. Very well done. "Drawing the wealthy through a portal..." At Dallas Social Venture Partners we do a "Venture Van" to take partners to areas of need. I wonder if something like that is being done in Chicago through the community foundations.

Harry

I wonder if any Prince Gautamas climb aboard these vans.

Phil

Go here for Guatama's awakening
http://mcel.pacificu.edu/mcel/omm/B1261.htm

Harry

To the elite, the competent or successful, is there anything more aggravating than the tyranny imposed by the feckless? There are people who have suffered misfortune; they brought it down on themselves and some odd neurosis inspires them to spread their mediocrity. Our goodwill towards mankind is their lever. Isn't it better for all concerned that the door be slammed in their faces?

They destroy morale, undercut the performance of their betters and every so often you can see the smug, satisfied hatred for excellence shining out of their eyes as they contemplate the ruin they have made of others' painstaking efforts.

Dealing with them becomes a serious problem if they are members of our subtribe. We are all inclined to draw talent from the pool we know best, who speak the language we know, whose first premises so nearly match our own. It's a reasonably sound practice. The learning curve is less steep for them and we imagine, rightly or wrongly, that backgound will determine performance. If nothing else, they know what is expected and the basic desire not to disappoint will inspire a certain amount of effort. Bringing shame and failure to the subtribe is anti-survival.

These are the people who must not be cut any slack at all. They will fail their way upwards, given half a chance, and become entrenched in decision making positions; attempting to create a safe niche for them within an organization is a terrible mistake.

How much better off would everyone be if the young man who had displayed cowardice, a fondness for drugs and liquor, lack of empathy or understanding and an inability to perform the simplest tasks set for him had faced society's prescribed justice? Giving that young man the opportunity to find redemption through honest physical labor and counseling, should he show the ability to benefit thereby, is better for all, I think. Elevating him to high office -- the highest office, perhaps -- is a slap in the face to all who have done more starting from less fortunate first circumstances. But I digress.

Situations must be found for people who, for one reason or another, have displayed an inability to cope. This could be called nannyism, accurately, for their basic problems almost always include some degree of immaturity.

It's even better to forestall failure by early mentoring. A problem caught before it's compounded by repeated errors bears no burden of opprobrium and shattered sense of self-worth. Mentoring can benefit people who show the will to improve. There's nobility to nurturing that spark. I would also argue that meeting the basic survival needs of the wholly unsalvageable has secondary benefits. If nothing else, it's cheaper than prison.

Phil Cubeta

Harry, would you like brandy and a cigar? A little philanthropy, a little brie? Seriously, get out of that over-stuffed wingback chair. We are there to clean the common roon, not make policy.

Harry

Oops! I thought I was posting to Wealth Bondage. Too much brandy. . .

klaius

Istiophorus platypterus
has unmatched velocity.
Damn the obstreperous,
who tear the nets of reciprocity.

Phil Cubeta

Klaius, building bonds of reciprocity goes best sans poetry? I mean, if we want a comprehensive, all-inclusive, network. Poetry would drastically limit our chances.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

About

Wealth Bondage Premium Content

  • Castle by the Sea
    Provided as a professional courtesy at no extra charge to those with net worth of $25 million or more and/or family income of $500,000 a year or more, and to their Serving Professionals of all genders.